Tritheism and Ellen G. White
Excerpted from Who
is the Adventist Jesus by evangelical writer and researcher Elmer
Wiebe, published in 2006. Wieber is a Protestant speaking against the
Adventist claim to be Trinitarian. His conclusion (as an outsider) is
that Ellen G. White did not believe in or uphold or teach the full deity
of Jesus Christ and the Triune God.
"With the evidence of at least ten different prominent Seventh-day
Adventist leaders, we see by looking at their quotes that they were
not in agreement with addressing God as the Triune God. All the early
Adventists either had an Arian or semi-Arian view of God where Jesus
was either created or at the least, didn't have the same nature as
God the Father. It is interesting that Ellen G. White referred to
the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit as being the three great powers,
the heavenly trio. In the worse case, this could be understood a tritheism
view of the Godhead, but at best, leaving the interpretation open
to all kinds of views of the Godhead with this sloppy language. Unlike
the Seventh-day Adventist Church today, she did not believe that persons
meant exactly the same as beings. The term being referred exclusively
to the Father and the Son who were personal beings. According to the
first chapter of "Why Was Sin Permitted?" in Patriarchs
and Prophets, the third highest being in heaven before the entrance
of sin, was Lucifer. How can one ever believe Ellen was a trinitarian,
when history so clearly declares that her husband and all the pioneers
of the SDA Church were semi-Arian? She was married to her husband
for thirty-five years and never once did she rebuke him for his belief.
Never once did she ever teach against the semi-Arian doctrine. In
fact, she never used the term Trinity, and she taught decidedly against
it. As a matter of fact, when you look at the language that Ellen
G. White and other Adventists used, it would be fairly safe to say
that the Adventist movement didn't become trinitarians in 1896, but
rather tritheistic in their view of the Godhead. While the modern
Seventh-day Adventists claim to hold to a trinitarian view point of
the Godhead, they have not resolved the issues of heresy set forth
by their predecessors in the Adventist movement of the tritheism heresy.
We know that Ellen White didn't believe in or teach the Trinity because:
- In 10,000 manuscripts; 100,000 pages; 25 million words about theological
issues, she never once used the word "Trinity" to describe
her view of the Godhead.
- In her writings, while she copied profusely from hundreds of theological
writers, many of whom were trinitarian, in some cases word for word,
page for page; yet she never included the word Trinity which those
she copied from had occasion for the word.
- She had scores of Arian references to Jesus as the Son of God
before or at original creation, or as lesser deity from the Father.
- She had hundreds--if not more--references to the Godhead, yet
never used the word Trinity to describe the Christian God.
- There are scores of references to the three persons, or powers,
etc. of the Godhead, yet never the word Trinity to describe the
- In her seventy years of prophetic ministry, with scores of SDA
leaders who publicly spoke and wrote against the Trinity, whose
words she publicly endorsed, she never once corrected their false
anti-trinitarian views in favour of the triune God.
- However, she does have a blatant statement against all other fallen
Babylonish Protestant and Catholic churches that All their
prayers and professions are an abomination to God whereby
she has condemned the profession of the Trinity, which is one of
the primary confessions of the historic Christian Faith.
"From the above, no other conclusion can be drawn than that
Ellen G. White did not believe in or uphold or teach the full deity
of Jesus Christ and the Triune God." --Ibid. pp. 161-162.